Here is a common scenario in my practice: Mom and Dad wanted to help their son, Jake, buy a first home. The bank would only lend him so much, so they offered to lend him $100,000, informally, to cover the balance, with a plan for Jake to pay them back “when he could.” When I sit with clients in this situation, my first question is always “is this a gift, or is this a loan?” Most people view the situation as a hybrid of sorts. It is a “loan,” but they are not concerned about repayment since it is their child. They just know they want to help, and the details feel like something to sort out later, but sometimes, later is too late to protect both yourself and your child.
I understand the instinct. Nobody wants to hand their child a stack of legal paperwork when he or she is excited about a house. But money that moves between family members without a clear label doesn’t stay neutral. It eventually gets a label, and sometimes that label is the farthest thing from your original intent. Another child calls it favoritism. A divorce court calls it marital property. The IRS calls it a taxable gift. Sometimes, that argument plays out in probate court (when, admittedly, it is no longer your problem), where a family member who was never on the receiving end of a similar “loan” has every incentive to push for one label over the other.
So, what is the right answer, loan or gift? The answer is always “it depends.” There are good reasons for making a gift. First, it may be an effective use of your lifetime gift and estate tax exemption. Second, it eliminates the need for any paperwork beyond the filing of a gift tax return for the year the gift is made. And, third, it avoids the issue of imputed interest, where you end up paying income tax on income you do not actually receive.
Similarly, a loan has its own advantages. First, it preserves your lifetime gift and estate tax exemption, because money you genuinely expect to be repaid is not a gift and therefore not subject to transfer tax. Second, it keeps things even-handed among your children, since a documented loan can be repaid, deliberately forgiven, or counted against an inheritance instead of quietly resented. Third, it offers protection if your child’s circumstances change, because a promissory note and a recorded mortgage keep the loan proceeds and real property out of a divorce and unavailable to your child’s creditors.
Generally, certain characteristics distinguish a loan from a gift, and the key is documentation. A signed promissory note or loan agreement, a documented interest rate (which should, at a minimum, equal the IRS’s published rate for family loans), a repayment schedule, proof of payments, and, when the loan proceeds are being used to purchase real estate, a mortgage against the property being purchased are all evidence of the intent of the money transfer.
The loan/gift determination is crucial, as the distinction and its ramifications raise several questions upon a parent’s death. Was the “loan” forgiven? Is it still owed? Should it be treated as an advance against that child’s inheritance? If the loan exceeds the child’s inheritance, does the estate have an obligation to collect on the loan? If no payments are made, was it actually a gift with no impact on the estate? If the transaction is not properly documented, siblings are often the ones left arguing about the answer and usually in front of a judge who has no way to know what the parent actually intended.
If the determination is that the help is a loan, I tell clients to treat a family loan exactly like a business would. Put the terms in writing before the money moves, not after. Set an interest rate at or above the IRS’s Applicable Federal Rate. Decide up front, in the document, whether unpaid amounts at death are forgiven, deducted from that child’s share, or still owed to the estate. If real estate is involved, consider securing the loan with a recorded mortgage. None of this takes the warmth out of helping a child buy a home.
The Bayer Bottom Line
- Decide, in writing, whether the money given to a family member is a loan or a gift before it moves, not after.
- A real loan needs a signed note, an adequate interest rate, a repayment schedule, and often security.
- Spell out what happens to any unpaid balance if the parent dies before the loan is repaid.
- The paperwork protects the relationship as much as the money.
—
This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws vary and individual circumstances differ. Consult a licensed Connecticut attorney for guidance specific to your situation.
—